hall of shame (1938)

Brubaker Backs Into Baseball’s Hall of Shame” (Headline). Associated Press, St. Petersburg Times, May 1, 1938, p25 (Headline on AP article about Pittsburgh’s Bill Brubaker tying the record for most errors (4) by a third baseman in one game.)
NOTE: There are earlier examples that suggested putting a player or manager into the “Hall of Shame,” but this is the earliest after the formation of an actual Hall of Fame.

No earliest use given in 2009 Dickson Baseball Dictionary